Three attitudes toward collapse

Collapse has become one of the dominant future imaginaries of our time. It rarely arrives as a single event. More often it looks like what William Gibson calls The Jackpot: slow, multicausal, already underway. Once people expect it, they start to act on that expectation. I distinguish three attitudes.

Escapism. “If X happens, I’m leaving.” Since the political shift to the right in many Western countries, this sentence has turned up in more and more conversations. Usually it comes with a country in mind and an event that would set it off. The attitude is passive: collapse happens elsewhere, and the plan is to be gone when it comes.

Prepping. It shows in bunkers, exit strategies and property in New Zealand. Douglas Rushkoff has described this as “The Mindset” of the tech elite: the belief that enough wealth can buy insulation from the consequences of the world it helped build.1 The attitude is defensive. Collapse will come, so the task is to wall oneself off.

Acceleration. This is the newest of the three and the one coming out of Silicon Valley. Its premise is that artificial general intelligence will fundamentally change work, the economy and society. The conclusion is to get as rich and as well positioned as possible before it does. The short version is: get rich before the rapture. Effective Accelerationism supplies the doctrine: the change cannot be stopped, so it should be sped up. The attitude is offensive, and it carries an irony. The people building the thing they expect to break the world are the same people preparing for the break.

The three differ in what they do. They share what comes before. Kim Stanley Robinson calls it “preemptive capitulation”: “giving up before you have to in hopes of reducing the harm that will come to you.”2 Fleeing, walling off and speeding up are three answers to a future that has already been accepted as lost.

That acceptance has consequences of its own. When everyone builds survival strategies, collapse turns into a self-fulfilling prophecy. The expectation shapes the behavior that produces the outcome.

The alternative starts with a different question. Anti-dystopia asks what to work against. Robinson’s line points the other way: “Utopia is not a destination but a direction.”2 Which direction would each of the three attitudes look for, if it stopped asking how to survive and started asking how we want to live?

  1. Douglas Rushkoff, Survival of the Richest: Escape Fantasies of the Tech Billionaires, W. W. Norton, 2022. ↩

  2. Kim Stanley Robinson in conversation with Future Histories, Season 3, Episode 55, January 2026. Video excerpt: “Futurecide” and “Preemptive Capitulation”. ↩ ↩2


Note Graph

ESC